Failures in Afghanistan

Written by on August 17, 2021

Earlier than exiting Afghanistan, the American authorities didn’t absolutely recognize the facility of the Taliban, how rapidly the federal government would fall or the rift between Afghans and the U.S. We’re republishing our investigation from final yr a couple of lethal airstrike — considered one of many — that contributed to the place we’re right this moment.

AZIZABAD, Afghanistan – As soon as the People left, the survivors began digging.

There have been too many lifeless and never sufficient shovels, so a neighborhood politician introduced in heavy equipment from a close-by development web site. He dug graves deep sufficient to suit moms with youngsters, or youngsters with youngsters. Some had been nonetheless of their pajamas, their palms inked with henna tattoos from the celebration preparations the night time earlier than.

Villagers picked by means of the rubble of what had been a whole neighborhood, on the lookout for stays to wrap in white linens for burial. A boy clutching a torn rug walked in a daze on prime of the ruins. A younger man collapsed in grief by a pile of mud bricks the place his house as soon as stood – the place his spouse and 4 youngsters had been sleeping inside.

The native physician recorded a cellphone video to doc the lifeless faces, freckled with shrapnel and blood, coated with mud and particles. Some had been Afghan males of combating age, however most – dozens of them – had been ladies and youngsters. Taza was Three years outdated. Maida was 2. Zia, 1.

The new summer time wind kicked up mud, smoke and the scent of gunpowder as villagers tried to make sense of why their distant village was demolished by an American airstrike in the midst of the night time.

A clue was discovered close to a number of of the lifeless Afghan fighters: ID badges from the personal safety firm on the American-controlled airfield up the highway.

Why had a workforce of U.S. troopers and Marines battled its personal paid safety element?

After greater than a decade, those that buried their households nonetheless don’t know.

U.S. navy officers publicly touted the August 22, 2008, Azizabad raid – Operation Commando Riot – as a victory. A high-value Taliban goal had been killed; the collateral injury was minimal; the village was grateful.

None of it was true.

The Taliban commander escaped. Dozens of civilians had been lifeless within the rubble, together with as many as 60 youngsters. The native inhabitants rioted.

It stays one of many deadliest civilian casualty occasions of the Afghan marketing campaign. However the story of how the operation turned tragic has been largely hidden from the general public.

USA TODAY spent greater than a yr investigating the Azizabad raid and sued the Division of Protection to acquire virtually 1,000 pages of investigative information beforehand stored secret as a result of it had been deemed “labeled nationwide safety data.” The information included images of the destruction in Azizabad and sworn testimony from the U.S. forces who deliberate and executed the operation.

USA TODAY additionally obtained Afghan authorities information, proof collected by humanitarian teams, together with the Crimson Cross, and a confidential United Nations investigation into the incident.

As well as, a reporter traveled to western Afghanistan to interview authorities officers, investigators, first responders, witnesses and the villagers who survived.

MORE: How we reported the lethal airstrike: A reporter’s pocket book from Afghanistan

Collectively, the information and interviews inform the story of a catastrophe that was months within the making as navy and firm officers ignored warnings concerning the males they’d employed to offer intelligence and safety. The information additionally reveal that the Protection Division has for years downplayed or denied the deadly errors surrounding the tragedy.

The issues started in 2007 when ArmorGroup, a personal safety firm engaged on a Pentagon subcontract, employed two native warlords on the U.S. intelligence payroll to offer armed guards at an airfield on the western fringe of Afghanistan.

These warlords fought one another for management of the weapons and cash ArmorGroup was giving out. The tangle of espionage and tribal infighting ultimately drew in the exact same navy items that had helped empower the warlords within the first place.

The breakdowns within the U.S. navy intelligence machine culminated with the raid itself. Some troops had been by no means warned of Azizabad’s civilian inhabitants, and the particular operations commanders who did know unleashed devastating pressure from the air anyway. Floor troops directed an American gunship to demolish home after home the place at the least one rebel took cowl, with out understanding who else was inside.

“In the event that they fled into the constructing, we had been asking him to mainly drop the constructing,” a Marine who was coordinating with the gunship testified. Many of the names had been redacted from the navy investigation.

A lot concerning the mission in Azizabad stays in dispute, however this a lot is obvious: The architects behind this nook of the conflict – and people making the most of the safety contract – didn’t perceive the distinction between who they had been purported to be combating, using and defending.

There nonetheless isn’t any definitive dying toll. After initially insisting that solely 5 to seven civilians died, Pentagon officers had been compelled to regulate that determine to 33 after photographs and movies of the carnage proved the official account mistaken. Separate opinions by the Afghan authorities, Crimson Cross, United Nations and Afghan Unbiased Human Rights Fee put the civilian deaths over 70.

After two Pentagon investigations, the U.S. navy denied any wrongdoing. Protection Division officers declined to remark for this story.

A 2010 Senate Armed Providers Committee inquiry laid blame with each ArmorGroup and the Protection Division for doing enterprise with the warlords. In response to the Senate report, then-Protection Secretary Robert Gates issued a letter recognizing issues with contract oversight, which he pledged to repair.

An excerpt of sworn testimony taken from the fire control officer aboard the AC-130 gunship. The officer was in charge of selecting the munitions and coordinating with the ground team to shoot at targets in Azizabad.

But within the aftermath of the Azizabad raid, information present, navy leaders sought to current a picture of success and masks proof of a civilian casualty catastrophe. The false model of occasions was amplified by Oliver North – a former Marine commander and a key determine within the Iran-Contra scandal of the late 1980s – who was embedded as a Fox Information contributor with the forces conducting the raid. North’s phase, which presents the mission as a hit and the Taliban commander “confirmed lifeless,” continues to be obtainable on the Fox Information web site.

North didn’t reply to a number of interview requests. In an e-mail, Fox Information spokeswoman Caley Cronin didn’t handle North’s phase and directed inquiries to North, “who’s not a contributor with the community,” she wrote.

Lt. Colonel Rachel E. VanLandingham, a retired officer with the Decide Advocate Normal’s Corps and the chief of worldwide regulation at Central Command’s headquarters through the Azizabad raid, stated the commanders liable for investigating the incident appeared to disregard the failures as a substitute of studying from them. She didn’t know the main points of the operation or the navy’s response till contacted by USA TODAY.

“The CENTCOM investigation appeared extra fearful about wanting good than being good,” VanLandingham, now a regulation professor at Southwestern Legislation Faculty in Los Angeles, stated in an interview. “Everybody who deploys in Afghanistan ought to know this incident.”

Villagers picked through the rubble for days after the airstrike. The U.S. military officials originally said only five to seven civilians were killed. But they did not look beneath the rubble. They adjusted that figure to more than 30 later.

G4S, the most important personal safety firm on this planet, bought ArmorGroup in 2008 – after the corporate had signed its contract with the Pentagon to offer safety on the airfield however earlier than the Azizabad raid. The corporate’s position has remained nearly unknown apart from a literal footnote within the Senate inquiry.

Executives at ArmorGroup, which G4S dissolved into one other subsidiary it later offered in 2014, thought-about their choices on the time to be the best choice to maintain these inside the bottom secure below tough circumstances, in keeping with emails collected by Senate investigators.

“With out the management and administration” of firm workers, the “worst might have prompted the undertaking to fail lengthy earlier than the August tragedy,” one stated.

David McDonnell, a former ArmorGroup director who oversaw mine clearing initiatives in Afghanistan
“It was wholesale slaughter. And it didn’t should be.”

G4S declined to remark for this story, besides to state that ArmorGroup is a former G4S subsidiary that wasn’t below the direct management of the mother or father firm.

However a number of the staff who had been working the air base contracts close to Azizabad agreed to talk out publicly for the primary time.

“It was wholesale slaughter,” David McDonnell, a former ArmorGroup director who oversaw mine clearing initiatives in Afghanistan, stated in a current interview. “And it didn’t should be.”

His colleague, Tony Thompson, labored with a number of the villagers killed within the raid. Thompson advised USA TODAY he has spent a lot of the previous decade wrestling with the reality stored secret all this time.

“Their households died, they usually nonetheless don’t know why,” he stated. “You’ll by no means deliver them again. However you should understand how and why it occurred.”

I. The Airfield

The Shindand District air base, on the southern border of Afghanistan’s Herat Province, was first constructed by the Soviets within the 1960s. A graveyard of deserted Russian plane and land mines unfold throughout open fields on either side of the perimeter fence. The bottom is a 9-square-mile campus in a distant however strategic location between Iran’s japanese border and the Ring Street, which circles all of Afghanistan.

In a district that has lengthy been managed or contested by the Taliban, the airbase sits amid a serious drug and arms trafficking route. The Taliban funds a lot of its nationwide operation with the opium-poppy fields within the district’s Zerkoh Valley.

In April 2007, ArmorGroup – a personal safety firm based mostly in London – gained a $5.1 million Air Drive subcontract to protect development staff constructing an growth of the airfield for the Afghan Nationwide Military. (The corporate’s American subsidiary, ArmorGroup North America, based mostly in Virginia, technically managed the contract). ArmorGroup had labored in additional than 160 nations world wide and was recognized principally for shielding oil and fuel websites.

ArmorGroup agreed to a Pentagon requirement that it fill the guard positions by hiring close by villagers. It was a part of the Pentagon’s financial stimulus plan for Afghanistan, but it surely additionally was inexpensive than bringing in guards from exterior the nation.

“We’re a business firm, after all, we need to do the enterprise as low cost as attainable,” an organization official later advised U.S. navy investigators. 

Shindand’s 450 villages are a number of the most impoverished within the Herat Province. Many rural areas would not have working water or paved roads. Day laborers discover work wherever they’ll, together with throughout the border in Iran. A low-ranking Afghan Nationwide Police officer might earn roughly $70 a month.

At $275 a month, the guard jobs on the air base represented the very best alternative some would see in a lifetime. 

II. Mr. Pink and Mr. White

ArmorGroup officers had no say in whom they might rent to choose the villagers. Based on interviews and testimony, U.S. navy personnel instructed ArmorGroup managers to let two native males – Timor Shah and Nadir Khan – choose who might turn into guards.

The firm assigned them code names: Mr. White for Shah and Mr. Pink for Khan. The names had been an homage to Reservoir Canine, the Quentin Tarantino traditional movie during which thieves betray and homicide each other after an armed theft.

Mr. White and Mr. Pink, two native patriarchs and sons of Shindand, would workers the guard positions from their prolonged households. The boys had been cousins, lifelong associates and enterprise companions within the district. Their authentic operations included automotive leases and digital shops within the northern metropolis of Herat.

However U.S. intelligence and firm officers believed that each males had been burgeoning warlords with attainable prison and Taliban affiliations, in keeping with interviews with native officers, testimony within the Pentagon investigation and memos from the Senate inquiry.

In rural Afghanistan, the road between village elder, warlord and legit Taliban is usually blurred, which might confound outsiders attempting to trace allegiances on the bottom.

Allegations of Pink and White’s illicit backgrounds weren’t essentially an issue anyway. Navy intelligence officers contained in the airfield had been constructing an unlimited community of paid informants throughout the area, attractive them with cash in alternate for details about Taliban conferences and the situation of high-value targets.

White and Pink had been each intelligence property.

Lal Mohammad Umarzai, the Shindand governor at the time of the Azizabad raid, said he was never consulted about the possible implications of empowering White and Pink at the airfield.

Lal Mohammad Umarzai, the Shindand governor on the time of the Azizabad raid, stated he was by no means consulted concerning the attainable implications of empowering White and Pink on the airfield.
Brett Murphy, USA TODAY

Lal Mohammad Umarzai, the Shindand governor on the time, advised USA TODAY in an interview that he was by no means consulted concerning the knowledge of giving two warlords a whole bunch of hundreds of {dollars}, entry to an armory of computerized weapons and digital management over Shindand. The district is without doubt one of the most numerous in Afghanistan, with advanced tribal dynamics and a historical past of energy struggles.

Had any individual reached out to him for recommendation, Umarzai stated, he would have warned U.S. officers that White and Pink would deliver bother.

“They had been the 2 most corrupt households in Afghanistan,” Umarzai stated.

III. Parley in the bazaar

White and Pink initially break up the work down the center. They confirmed up in June 2007 exterior the fence of the airfield with about 20 males every.

Based on the Senate inquiry, ArmorGroup couldn’t show that it had despatched armed guard rosters or coaching information to the U.S. authorities, a violation of Division of Protection rules.

“Usually in a rustic, if we had been going to make use of native folks, they might be interviewed, qualification checks, names go to the federal government for safety backgrounds,” McDonnell stated in an interview. “None of that occurred in Shindand. The entire regular procedures we might perform didn’t occur as a result of we had been directed who to work with by the American forces.”

USA TODAY filed a public information request with the Air Drive for paperwork concerning the armed staff – information the company was required to gather and keep, in keeping with the contract. An Air Drive official stated these paperwork couldn’t be situated as a result of they “may not have been processed or archived … because of the delicate nature.”

Inside weeks of beginning the contract, Pink and White made the identical calculation: Controlling half of the cash and jobs was good. However having every part would make considered one of them untouchable.

They grew paranoid of one another. The resentment turned violent, and there have been a sequence of shootings and bombings round Shindand that officers would blame on the feud between the 2 males.

Pink made at the least one try on White’s life as he was leaving the air base. ArmorGroup officers grew more and more fearful that its guards would attempt to kill each other or go away their posts, in keeping with inside memos and emails compiled within the Senate inquiry.

In December 2007, tribal elders brokered a cease-fire and known as for White and Pink to settle their variations. A gathering was organized for Dec. 12 within the Azizabad bazaar, a brief strip of open-air retailers on both facet of the Ring Street.

White and Pink approached one another available in the market, the place villagers offered bread, fruit and residential home equipment.

Simply earlier than they reached one another, Pink pulled out a gun and shot White thrice. A gunfight broke out available in the market between ArmorGroup guards loyal to every man. A number of civilians had been wounded.

When the chaos ended, White was lifeless.

IV. The bombmaker

The Air Drive undertaking supervisor in Kabul reported the assassination to U.S. navy officers, in keeping with the Senate inquiry. However little modified.

“The incident didn’t give rise to a broader dialogue at (the Air Drive) concerning the knowledge of counting on two warlords to offer safety,” the investigators wrote.

Pink, nonetheless, misplaced his job as an informant. ArmorGroup additionally fired him from the air base.

Fearing retribution from White’s household, Pink went into hiding in a close-by village with native Taliban militia. He was later concerned in a sequence of kidnappings and different violent crimes, in keeping with intelligence reviews cited within the navy investigation and inside firm memos collected by the Senate investigators.

Navy officers on the base went so far as nominating Pink as a high-priority goal as a result of “he was a pressure safety drawback for the realm,” one Marine testified through the Pentagon investigation. However U.S. commanders denied the request and determined as a substitute to carefully monitor him.

The airfield development undertaking continued, and ArmorGroup wanted another person to deal with staffing guards on the air base.

So the firm employed Reza Khan, White’s brother. They known as him Mr. White II.

White II was one other intelligence asset for the navy personnel contained in the air base. In a single dialog together with his handler, he disclosed that his nephew was Mullah Sadeq, a infamous Taliban commander working within the Farah Province, simply south of Shindand. Sadeq constructed and equipped improvised explosive gadgets across the area.

The Italian navy had positioned Sadeq on the high-priority-target record. U.S. particular operations forces contained in the air base had been monitoring Sadeq for months in hopes of pinning down his actual location.

“It was actually no shock to us that (White II) had greater connections with the Taliban than beforehand suspected,” White II’s Marine intelligence handler testified through the Pentagon investigation. “He had been enjoying either side and finally we had been truly seeking to reduce his ties that he had with us.”

As an alternative, navy intelligence officers noticed him as the important thing to taking down Sadeq.

V. 'Meat in the sandwich'

In Could 2008, London-based personal safety big G4S purchased ArmorGroup for $85.Four million. The acquisition got here as the corporate expanded to greater than 100 nations and took on harmful enterprise a few of its rivals averted, together with mine clearing and base safety within the Center East.

The Shindand contract was already underway when G4S turned the company mother or father. The corporate left ArmorGroup operationally unbiased with the identical Afghanistan managers in place.

In July, Thompson, who labored for the corporate’s mine clearing division on a U.N. contract on the base, reported to executives in Afghanistan the risk White II posed. Thompson wrote that native police and the Afghan Nationwide Military had confiscated at White II’s Azizabad house stockpiles of unlicensed weapons and land mines. Guards had left the bottom with firm weapons to moonlight as White II’s private escorts.

Firm officers expressed in interviews with investigators “everlasting concern” a couple of full-scale conflict between militias loyal to Pink and White II. 

“I might hate to see our folks because the meat within the sandwich,” McDonnell, the corporate director, wrote in an e-mail responding to the report.

Information present that ArmorGroup officers handled their considerations about White II by asking him to offer a verbal assurance each week that the battle wouldn’t escalate.

Across the similar time, an Military Sergeant advised White II’s intelligence handler that the warlord was funneling cash from the air base contract – wages meant for the guards – straight to Taliban commanders. He was rebuffed.

“They learn about it,” the sergeant advised Senate investigators. “However they didn’t need to speak about it, for no matter purpose.”

VI. Rudderless

By the spring and summer time of 2008, particular operations forces misplaced at the least three of their very own within the space.  

On Could 29, Sergeant First Class David Nunez, 27, of Los Angeles was on his third deployment with the Military Particular Forces when his unit got here below hearth within the Farah Province desert plains. He was posthumously awarded the Silver Star for saving others from their automobile because it turned engulfed in flames. He had two sons.

A month later, 5 Marine particular operators with the Second Battalion had been gravely wounded whereas on the lookout for a Taliban commander. Marine Workers Sgt. Edgar Heredia died. Heredia, 28, was a local of Houston and the son of two Mexican immigrants.

On a separate mission within the Zerkoh Valley, Marine Captain Garrett “Tubes” Lawton, 31, died when an IED detonated by his automobile.

The leaders commanding these items had been dealing with intense scrutiny. Evening raids and air campaigns had been typically adopted by reviews of civilian casualties, an virtually inevitable final result when insurgents reside and battle amongst their civilian neighbors.

Frank Rosenblatt, a retired Lt. Colonel and JAG who has written a number of books and research concerning the navy justice system, known as 2008 “a time of strategic rudderlessness” for the U.S. marketing campaign in Afghanistan.

He stated navy leaders rushed into operations that could possibly be touted to the American public, typically at the price of the native inhabitants they had been purported to be defending.

“Commanders needed to be seen getting after it,” Rosenblatt stated.

Mir Abdul Kalik, the former deputy governor in Shindand, was part of the Afghan government delegation investigating civilian casualties in Azizabad.

Mir Abdul Kalik, the previous deputy governor in Shindand, was a part of the Afghan authorities delegation investigating civilian casualties in Azizabad.
Brett Murphy, USA TODAY

The Taliban used the civilian deaths to recruit new militia members, and Afghan residents grew more and more cautious of the ways of American forces.

“The Taliban are all the time telling folks, ‘Have a look at the People, they got here to kill you and your children,’” stated Mir Abdul Kalik, the previous deputy governor in Shindand. “An enormous hole has been created between the Afghans and the People.”

The sentiment had reached Kabul, the place then-Afghan President Hamid Karzai repeatedly condemned using American gunships in city areas.

“We are able to not settle for the civilian casualties the best way they’re occurring,” Karzai stated.

However the airstrikes continued. On July 6, an airstrike in Nangarhar province inadvertently killed 47 Afghan civilians, misidentified as insurgents, throughout a marriage. Two weeks later, one other airstrike by accident killed 9 Afghan Nationwide Law enforcement officials in Farah province.

VII. Romeo and Juliet

In August, two property – code-named Romeo and Juliet – advised their intelligence handler on the air base information he had been ready on for months: Mullah Sadeq was coming to satisfy his uncle, White II, at his house compound in Azizabad.

For the primary time for the reason that People had been monitoring him, Sadeq could be inside 20 miles of the bottom.

The knowledge was met with skepticism. Romeo and Juliet had been recognized associates of Mr. Pink, so intelligence officers thought-about the chance that Pink might have orchestrated the leak as a approach to have U.S. forces assault White II. Was this a setup?

“I’ve thought of that earlier than,” one of many intelligence officers later testified within the navy investigation. “However these guys, they offer me fairly dependable data on who, what, when, and the place.”

Romeo and Juliet had offered good intelligence for missions into the Zerkoh Valley that summer time. Plus, the intelligence workplace reckoned, White II himself had corroborated his relationship to Sadeq.

It was too good of a chance to cross up. As a bonus, Oliver North and a Fox cameraman would tag alongside for the mission for his or her ongoing “Struggle Tales” dispatches.

The regional commanders green-lighted an operation to seize or kill Sadeq and accepted an AC-130 gunship, typically dubbed “hell within the sky,” for shut air assist. Operation Commando Riot was a go.

Within the days earlier than Sadeq was scheduled to reach, the U.S. forces on the base labored with Afghan commandos to attract up a minute-by-minute plan.

Romeo and Juliet stated Sadeq would present up with greater than two dozen militia someday earlier than midnight for a gathering inside White II’s compound. The home was surrounded by different houses on three sides and a big courtyard to the southeast. Every construction was constructed with mud bricks as dense as concrete. A huge alley led on to the compound.

Romeo and Juliet had a contact attending the assembly who would name as quickly as Sadeq arrived.

To keep up the ingredient of shock, the mission would should be a scalpel, not a sledgehammer.

Driving pickup vehicles, a workforce of 12 from the Second Marine Particular Operations Battalion would lead the strike. Military Particular Forces and Afghan commandos would comply with 10 minutes behind. The full assault pressure could be roughly 80 males.

Captain Elliot Ackerman could be the assault pressure commander with the Marines entering into first.

She survived the airstrike that killed her household

Gul Rukh survived the air strike that killed her household, however needs she hadn’t.

Video by Brett Murphy, Shahpoor Sabir, Aleem Agha and Jasper Colt, USA TODAY

Ackerman, 28 on the time, was commissioned as an officer proper after school. He had earned quite a few medals, together with the Silver Star for saving fellow Marines 4 years earlier through the second battle of Fallujah, the bloodiest engagement of the Iraq Struggle.

As a result of a lot of the names had been redacted from the testimony within the navy investigation, it’s not clear whether or not Ackerman was the commander who finally led all the Azizabad operation. He declined a number of interview requests for this story. 

The legal guidelines of conflict require that every one possible precautions are taken to keep away from harming civilians. To cut back collateral injury, consultants and activists urge a “sample of life evaluation” – hours of reconnaissance within the goal space forward of a mission so everybody entering into, together with air assist, understands what number of civilians are current and the place they’re situated.

However in Shindand, the troops had been relying largely on third-hand data and a common understanding of villages within the space, the intelligence officers later advised investigators. Even the intelligence property, Romeo and Juliet, had not not too long ago visited Azizabad themselves for worry of being recognized.

A lead intelligence officer and a Marine commander had been conscious {that a} funeral ceremony for households was deliberate for the day after Sadeq was set to reach, in keeping with their testimony with navy investigators. Nevertheless, virtually everyone else concerned with the planning and execution of operation Commando Riot testified that they weren’t advised a couple of civilian gathering.

“Everyone that was going to be at that assembly had been Taliban commanders with their safety guys,” a communications sergeant testified later. “There wasn’t purported to be any ladies and youngsters.”

It’s unclear why that data was not broadly recognized or whether or not it had been reported up the chain of command earlier than the mission and the gunship had been accepted.

VIII. The Rukh family

The morning of August 21, Gul Rukh piled her 4 children into her cousin’s automotive and headed north on the Ring Street to her mother and father’ home in Azizabad. A whole bunch of villagers across the Zerkoh Valley and Farah Province had obtained invites to commemorate the dying of a distinguished village elder eight months earlier.

His identify was Timor Shah – also called the unique Mr. White.

Rukh, 39, stopped within the metropolis of Shindand to go looking for the ceremony. She purchased new garments for her children and a wood chest to maintain tchotchkes. It was the kind of splurging Rukh reserved just for particular events.

After they arrived in Azizabad that night, households gathered within the courtyard round out of doors hearth pits and bought to cooking. They slaughtered 16 sheep and cooked rice in metal drums.

Hundreds of villagers around the Zerkoh Valley and Farah Province had received invitations to commemorate the death of Timor Shah (also known as Mr. White.) After the raid, those who survived showed the local reporters and government investigators the invitations.

Rukh’s sons, Dawa, 10, Ghani, 6, and Nabi, 5, and her daughter, Rahima, 9, spent a lot of the sunlight hours kicking a soccer ball with their cousins. When the solar went down, the youngsters darted between homes enjoying disguise and search. They painted henna tattoos on each other’s palms.

As soon as a lot of the meals was ready, households peeled off for mattress. The homes had been too full, so many camped within the courtyard. It was cool sufficient to sleep exterior comfortably, and the fortunate ones had mosquito nets.

Rukh stayed up previous midnight speaking together with her mother and father, principally listening, whereas they tried persuading her to remain a few further days after the ceremony. They lastly drifted off to sleep.

IX. Commando Riot

The decision from the contact contained in the compound got here simply earlier than 1:30 a.m.: Sadeq is right here.

Whereas the troops mounted into their vehicles, a soldier knocked on the trailers across the garrison to roust North and the Fox cameraman. North emerged in navy fatigues and night time imaginative and prescient goggles and headed towards the convoy.

“What the hell was Oliver North doing there?” McDonnell, one of many ArmorGroup administrators, stated in a current interview. “He wasn’t passing by means of for a cup of tea. This was set as much as placed on a present.”

The intelligence officers who helped plan the mission climbed to the highest of the garrison barracks and confronted Azizabad, 18 miles to the south. They watched the AC-130 cross overhead.

The Marines within the two lead pickup vehicles turned off the Ring Street and towards the compound round 2 a.m. They heard a single pop from a rifle. That was the warning shot alerting the compound that enemies had been incoming.

They noticed a lightweight on in White II’s compound. The vehicles rumbled over the filth, by means of a slender passage with partitions on both sides at the least Eight ft excessive.

A water truck parked on the close to finish of the alley blocked the route into the compound. The Marines hopped out to proceed on foot.

Gunshots poured in from the west and north. The hearth felt as if it was coming from straight above.

Bullets peppered the partitions subsequent to the crouching Marines. They returned hearth to the rooftops, the place they might see flashes from rifle bursts by means of their night time imaginative and prescient goggles. It was essentially the most fixed, correct hearth a few of them had ever skilled since coming to Afghanistan, they testified later.

Marine Gunnery Sgt. Joseph “Willy” Guardian took a spherical by means of his foot.

They had been pinned down. The commander shot two pink flares into the air so the opposite items trailing behind might discover them. He would later testify that he didn’t think about retreat a viable choice.

“For the fame and simply the credibility of coalition,” the commander stated, including that withdrawing from a battle with the Taliban when you find yourself up to now dedicated is “fully inconceivable and unacceptable.”

The 12 Marines who had exited the vehicles moved right into a constructing, the place a girl and baby had been huddled within the nook. There, the Marines arrange a base of operations.

The commander advised the radio controller subsequent to him to name the gunship within the air, circling at 10,000 ft. The enemy was “hazard shut.”

The controller yelled into the radio for quick hearth on the insurgents approaching them within the alley.

The gunship crew heard panic on the opposite line and set to work. They used high-powered cameras to scan across the courtyard and the encompassing buildings.

Then, they unleashed 40-millimeter and howitzer rounds into the alley and onto rooftops. Some exploded above the bottom and flung 14,000 shrapnel fragments per spherical right into a rainbow sample.

Some targets gave the impression to be working, and others had been taking on positions. However figuring out folks from the air alone was unimaginable, the pilot would later inform investigators.

It was like going “out right into a discipline in the midst of the night time on a couple of quarter moon mild, and also you see a darkish form shifting by means of the sphere,” the pilot stated. 

For 2 hours, the air crew coordinated with the commander on the bottom to blast aside buildings the place the enemy fighters took up positions. Troops lay inclined on the far facet of a domed roof to peek throughout the courtyard and relay data to the gunship.

“In the event that they fled into the constructing, we had been asking him to mainly drop the constructing,” the controller on the bottom later testified.

The gunship blasted room by room, home by home, till there was no one left capturing.

In complete, the gunship fired 82 howitzer rounds and 242 of the 40-millimeter rounds. The barrage ended with a 500-pound bomb dropped onto White II’s compound.

X. Aftermath

Daylight broke by means of the clouds of mud and smoke.

Rukh couldn’t really feel her legs. Shrapnel had shredded her backbone.

Her listening to was muffled behind a low hum, however she was acutely aware and noticed every part. By the particles, she might make out her oldest son’s pistachio pajamas. He was lifeless. And so was her mom, who was only a few ft away.

The remainder of her household was beneath the rubble of a clay roof, 18 inches thick, that had collapsed to the bottom. They had been crushed to dying. Rukh desperately cried out for a glass of water.

The American forces discovered her and two youngsters – not her personal – nonetheless respiration. They pulled them from the rubble, which was chest deep in areas the place the roofs had collapsed. One baby died virtually instantly. The opposite, a 5-year-old woman named Kobra, was shaking as they carried her to a medic. Her face was vacant and coated in mud.

An Afghan boy carried a torn rug next to his destroyed home in Azizabad the day after the raid.

An Afghan boy carried a torn rug subsequent to his destroyed house in Azizabad the day after the raid.
Fraidoon Pooyaa, AP

The troops photographed what was left of different insurgents’ our bodies – however solely these seen above the rubble. Altogether, they discovered seven lifeless males with weapons round them and 6 lifeless civilians.

Among the many lifeless was White II.

The supply who known as Romeo and Juliet to substantiate Sadeq had arrived was additionally lifeless. “He took one for the workforce,” a navy official testified. 

The troops cordoned off the neighborhood for 3 hours whereas a workforce of Military Particular Forces operators went door to door with the Afghan commandos to clear the buildings and gather weapons, explosives and paperwork. They blew up a cache of land mines in one of many buildings.

There was no signal of Sadeq.

Simply after 9 a.m., the convoy left for the air base with what they’d seized: 14 computerized rifles, 15 mines, 4,000 bullets, 32 magazines, stacks of U.S. and Afghan foreign money, 19 cellphones, packing containers of paperwork – and ArmorGroup ID badges discovered close to a number of the lifeless males.

Additionally they left with 5 prisoners in blindfolds. Two of them had been ArmorGroup guards on the air base.

The convoy returned to a barbeque on the airfield.

“It was simply one thing I’ve by no means skilled earlier than: singing and dancing and everyone gave the impression to be comfortable,” stated Thompson, who had simply discovered a number of of his staff had been doubtless killed. “The entire thing was a bit surreal.”

Thompson’s colleague despatched a determined report back to the Air Drive over considerations the surviving staff may flip their weapons on each other or the boys inside the bottom in revenge.

“We’re at present on full alert and expect as soon as the lifeless are buried an assault of some kind,” ArmorGroup Senior Crew Chief Nigel McCreery wrote.

All 43 native guards deserted the bottom to go search for their members of the family.

“At the moment I’m not sure as to what number of (ArmorGroup) native guards who had been off obligation have been killed or wounded,” McCreery wrote.

“The subsequent 24hrs will inform the story.”

Oliver North was embedded with the Marines and soldiers on Operation Commando Riot as a contributor for Fox News. The Fox segment, accompanying online story and chapter in North's book presented a false depiction of a successful mission.

After a week-long inquiry, Central Command stated in a press launch that the raid disrupted a deliberate assault on the air base and greater than 30 Taliban fighters had been killed. “The proof steered” Sadeq was amongst them, the assertion stated. The discharge claimed that 5 to seven civilians additionally died.

Fox Information ran a phase hosted by North “confirming that Mullah Sadeq is lifeless.” The report included footage of Rukh and Kobra being stabilized on the air base earlier than surgical procedure. He didn’t report the truth that Rukh was paralyzed or that Kobra died within the hospital quickly after.

North additionally wrote a chapter concerning the raid in his ebook, “American Heroes in Particular Operations.”

It appeared the U.S. “had achieved a surprising success,” he stated in his ebook and a web based story accompanying the Fox video.

After the raid, the Azizabad villagers picked by means of the rubble and compiled a listing of the lifeless: 91 complete, together with 60 youngsters.

Then they rioted. Confused and livid, about 200 villagers marched on the Ring Street hurling rocks at reporters and cops. They set hearth to an Afghan Nationwide Military automobile and shot at troopers.

In entrance of native tv cameras, the villagers held up their ArmorGroup badges, proof of their loyalty to the U.S. forces. They confirmed the invites to the funeral commemoration, proof of a civilian gathering, not a Taliban assembly.

During a riot after the raid, security guards from the airbase who survived were confused and furious. They flashed their ArmorGroup badges in front of reporters' cameras to show their alliance with coalition forces.

Throughout a riot after the raid, safety guards from the airbase who survived had been confused and livid. They flashed their ArmorGroup badges in entrance of reporters’ cameras to indicate their alliance with coalition forces.
Fraidoon Pooyaa

This model of occasions was diametrically reverse to what the Pentagon and North’s Fox Information phase had offered. Amongst skeptical Afghan and even some ArmorGroup officers, it appeared believable that Mr. Pink had duped U.S. forces into taking down his bitter rival.

“You bought at hand it to Pink,” an ArmorGroup supervisor wrote in an e-mail collected by the Senate investigators, “fairly shrewd.”

XI. Denials from the Pentagon

President Karzai was simply ending a lunch assembly within the presidential palace corridor in Kabul when authorities officers from Shindand walked in carrying a white linen, bundled up like a bag.

They waited for everybody to complete consuming and unwrapped the contents on the ground: Severed fingers from Azizabad. Too small to be from grownup males.

“Everyone was weeping that,” Mohammad Omar Daudzai, Karzai’s former chief of workers, stated in an interview.

During the riot after the raid, villagers threw rocks at Afghan police, set fire to a police vehicle and chased away government officials.

Throughout the riot after the raid, villagers threw rocks at Afghan police, set hearth to a police automobile and chased away authorities officers.
Fraidoon Pooyaa, AP

After a telephone name with then-President George W. Bush, Karzai flew to the Shindand airfield, the place he met with reporters and a crowd of locals. He condemned the “irresponsible and imprecise” navy operation. 

“I’ve been working day and night time previously 5 years to stop such incidents, however I have never been profitable,” Karzai stated. “If I had succeeded, the folks of Azizabad would not be bathed in blood.”

Karzai paid $2,000 for every of the 91 victims. It was the usual solatia, “blood cash,” fee for mourners. He additionally promised to rebuild the destroyed houses in Azizabad.

Karzai fired the Afghan Nationwide Military Normal who was answerable for the Afghan commandos on the mission. He ordered his intelligence company to arrest Mr. Pink for offering false data to the Particular Operations forces.

An Afghan woman mourns during a ceremony in Azizabad. She is holding a poster with photos of her family member killed in the August 22 raid.

An Afghan lady mourns throughout a ceremony in Azizabad. She is holding a poster with photographs of her member of the family killed within the August 22 raid.
Fraidoon Pooyaa, AP

Within the days and weeks that adopted, investigators from the U.N., Afghan Unbiased Human Rights Fee and Crimson Cross flew into Shindand to analyze the dying toll discrepancy.

Worldwide media shops printed extra accounts from witnesses and the geopolitical firestorm it had created between Washington and Kabul. New York Occasions journalist Carlotta Gall reported new proof from the bottom – together with one other baby’s physique she found – which raised extra questions concerning the American narrative.

However the Pentagon continued to publicly declare Sadeq had been killed, and officers denied to the media that there had been mass civilian casualties. On the similar time, navy officers labored behind the scenes to steer the narrative again in a extra favorable mild.

Abdul Salam Qazizad, a neighborhood politician who was a part of the Afghan authorities’s delegation to Azizabad, was known as to the Shindand air base two weeks after the raid, he stated in an interview.

He stated two navy officers offered the U.S. forces’ viewpoint and requested him to stroll again statements he had made on tv about mass civilian casualties.

Abdul Salam Qazizad was part of the Afghan government’s delegation to Azizabad. In the aftermath, he was vocal about the civilian casualties. He said the U.S. military called him to the airbase and asked him to walk back his public statements.

“However I advised them, ‘I’m not doing that,’” Qazizad recalled. “‘People make errors. You made a mistake. Come and inform the folks that you simply made it.’”

The Afghan Unbiased Human Rights Fee obtained the same message from the U.S. authorities. Ahmad Nader Nadery was head of the group on the time and now leads the Afghan authorities’s administrative reform and civil service fee.

He summarized the group’s findings for Pentagon officers, together with the massive variety of civilian deaths.

“They stated, ‘That is all bulls—t,’” Nadery recalled in an interview. “I ended the assembly and stated, ‘Properly, thanks.’”

XII. The Callan investigation

Brigadier Gen. Michael Callan’s telephone rang at 1 a.m. one night time in early September.  Callan, a embellished pilot, was having fun with the sundown of a three-decade navy profession on the U.S. Ramstein Air Base in Germany. A name like this was uncommon.

On the opposite finish of the telephone was somebody claiming to be Maj. Gen. Jay Hood, chief of workers at Central Command in Tampa, Fla. He stated he had a secret project for Callan in Afghanistan.

Callan thought it was a prank telephone name and went again to mattress.

A number of days later, after extra telephone calls and official emails confirmed the scenario, Callan stated goodbye to his spouse and children and boarded a flight to Kabul.

A grainy cellphone video had emerged, taken from the native physician from contained in the Azizabad mosque. It confirmed a chaotic scene of dozens of our bodies lined up and wrapped in linens whereas survivors wailed.

The Pentagon might not keep its public place and was compelled to open a brand new, full-scale investigation. Callan was picked to guide it.

He had by no means dealt with such an inquiry earlier than, however he reckoned his expertise as a particular operations pilot certified him for the job. His workforce included two navy attorneys, two Marines, two Military majors and a translator.

“Our mission was to get the details on what occurred that night time,” Callan wrote in a press release to USA TODAY. “Given the heightened media consideration, we would have liked to give attention to this occasion, go away our ‘actual jobs’ behind and full the investigation.”

After assembly with Normal David McKiernan, then-commander of the Worldwide Safety Help Drive, Callan’s workforce fanned out to collect proof from the opposite organizations that had already investigated the Azizabad raid.

The United Nations, Crimson Cross, Afghan Unbiased Human Rights Fee and Afghan authorities investigations had differing views of what number of Taliban had been within the village, if there have been any in any respect.

The U.S. special operations forces seized weapons, land mines and bullets after the raid. They also found ArmorGroup ID badges carried by some of the dead men. This photo was one of many pieces of evidence collected by military investigators during the 15-6 investigation.

However what was clear to every group was the rely of the lifeless was far better than what the Pentagon had claimed.

The confidential U.N. report regarding the Azizabad raid, which has by no means been made public earlier than, is essentially the most exhaustive and methodical. The group’s accounting of the casualties included the identify of every sufferer, age, house village and father’s identify. The report consists of a number of photos of infants wrapped within the white linens. The investigators, who made 4 journeys to the village, famous the quantity might by no means be thought-about remaining or sure with out exhuming the our bodies.

“It’s evident that the low variety of injured is because of the truth that most, if not all, individuals current within the homes that had been destroyed the truth is died,” they wrote.

The U.N. investigation concluded that 10 of the combating age males who had been killed within the raid had been ArmorGroup staff and that a number of the weapons confiscated by the U.S. Forces belonged to the corporate.

U.N. investigators additionally tried to find out whether or not U.S. officers had visited the village after the raid to collect details within the quick aftermath.

“The reply from quite a few witnesses isn’t any,” the U.N. report states. “No forces have returned to the village for the reason that incident.”

XIII. 'There should have been consequences'

Callan met with U.N. officers in Kabul on Sept. 18. He requested them to indicate him their investigation and the proof they’d collected in Azizabad, in keeping with inside U.N. communications and memos.

Emails present the U.N. officers had been cautious of trusting the Bush administration “to confess culpability for wrong-doing.” However they determined it was finest to offer their inquiry and a few supporting proof with the understanding that Callan’s workforce would coordinate the ultimate U.S. report with them earlier than something went public.

Two weeks later, U.S. Central Command, led on the time by Lt. Normal Martin Dempsey, printed a abstract of Callan’s findings. CENTCOM exonerated the navy of any conflict crimes, violations of the principles of engagement and most different allegations raised by the villagers. Callan’s workforce by no means briefed the U.N.

CENTCOM’s full 15-6 investigation, which incorporates greater than 1,500 pages of sworn testimony, images, movies and different proof, was by no means launched. The Pentagon denied journalists and activists who requested it, citing nationwide safety concerns.

USA TODAY obtained a lot of the information, however not the movies, after suing the Protection Division in 2018.

Afghan men look at a destroyed house in Azizabad the day after the raid. The mud roofs that collapsed on top of insurgents and civilians were dense as concrete and 18 inches thick.

Afghan males take a look at a destroyed home in Azizabad the day after the raid. The mud roofs that collapsed on prime of insurgents and civilians had been dense as concrete and 18 inches thick.
Fraidoon Pooyaa, AP

Callan’s govt abstract stated that 55 folks died in Azizabad after a proportional response from U.S. forces performing in self-defense: 33 civilians, together with 12 youngsters, and 22 anti-coalition insurgents, a few of whom had been doubtless staff of ArmorGroup.

It concluded that the Taliban violated the legal guidelines of conflict by selecting to battle alongside ladies and youngsters. CENTCOM dismissed villagers’ testimony a couple of greater rely of lifeless civilians.

“This may be akin to dismissing all eyewitness testimony throughout a prison trial performed within the U.S.,” a U.N. official wrote in an inside memo after the Pentagon made the abstract public.

CENTCOM didn’t acknowledge the intelligence breakdowns that left a lot of the pressure unaware of the funeral ceremony. It additionally didn’t clarify why regional commanders accepted using shut air assist for a number of hours regardless of data that ladies and youngsters had been within the village.

Lt. Colonel VanLandingham, the regulation professor and former chief of worldwide regulation at CENTCOM, stated these leaders appeared to fail to take all precautions to keep away from civilian hurt after which skirted accountability through the investigation.

“Heads ought to have rolled for that,” she stated. “There ought to have been penalties for that failure.”

An Afghan man who lost his relatives during the airstrike in Azizabad. He was waiting for a gathering in which then-Afghan President Hamid Karzai spoke to villagers and reporters about the incident on Sept. 4, 2008.

The general public abstract additionally didn’t embrace an array of testimony from U.S. forces that forged a destructive mild on what had occurred. For instance, Callan concluded that “Operation Commando Riot was not triggered by clan-on-clan rivalry.” Nevertheless, intelligence officers testified that the details about the Taliban assembly was sound however pushed by the feud between Pink and White.

Maybe most notably, the abstract didn’t admit that Sadeq had survived the raid. Intelligence officers advised the navy investigators he had most definitely escaped by means of an underground cavern simply north of the compound.

Sadeq “in keeping with our (human intelligence) sources, is alive and effectively in his conventional working space,” one of many officers testified. It’s unclear from the information whether or not Sadeq continues to be alive.

Callan didn’t reply to particular critiques of the investigation and the omissions from the general public abstract. In an e-mail to USA TODAY, he stated his workforce “unequivocally performed essentially the most complete evaluate of this mission of any investigation completed to this point.” They “left no stone unturned,” Callan stated. 

Within the public abstract, CENTCOM discounted proof collected by exterior inquiries, together with these from the U.N., as tainted by political or monetary agendas.

Former U.N. officers defended their work and the veracity of the investigation.

“We actually did need the People to cease killing folks. We actually did need the Talibs to cease killing folks,” Norah Niland, the Human Rights Director on the United Nations Help Mission in Afghanistan on the time, stated in a current interview. “That was the agenda.”

However U.N. officers determined in opposition to publicly criticizing the Pentagon’s shortfalls to keep away from “producing a variety of hostility,” in keeping with an inside U.N. memo.

“It isn’t advisable to reopen the difficulty once more,” they wrote.

XIV. Azizabad

Gul Rukh, whose mother and father and 4 youngsters died, now spends most of her days alone. She will peel potatoes or string collectively bracelets however is unable to maneuver something under her waist. She doesn’t have a wheelchair, so her brothers carry her round of their arms.

5 items of shrapnel are nonetheless embedded in her backbone. Medical doctors say they’ll’t get them out with out risking additional paralysis in her palms and tongue.

Gul Rukh, a survivor of the raid in Azizabad, is still paralyzed from the waist down from the shrapnel that embedded in her spine. She cannot afford a wheelchair so her brother must carry her.

Gul Rukh, a survivor of the raid in Azizabad, continues to be paralyzed from the waist down from the shrapnel that embedded in her backbone. She can’t afford a wheelchair so her brother should carry her.
Brett Murphy, USA TODAY

Rukh feels the identical approach now as she did when she first wakened within the hospital.

“I want I used to be lifeless too,” she stated in a current interview. She known as herself a burden on her household – extra like an object or piece of furnishings in the home, moderately than an individual dwelling in it.

“I bought accustomed to it,” Rukh stated, “and I misplaced hope.”

As we speak, the Taliban controls the Shindand District. Azizabad is in quiet ruins. Fewer than two dozen households reside there.

The homes leveled within the raid had been by no means repaired. The neighborhood is a pile of mud bricks and partitions scarred with bullet holes.

Daudzai, Karzai’s former chief of workers, stated he didn’t know the federal government had did not ship on its guarantees to rebuild Azizabad.

“We should always have executed it,” he stated in an interview. “We’re additionally equally responsible.”

A row of flat, marble tombstones stands upright within the cemetery close to the mosque. The epitaph over the grave of Reza Khan, recognized to some as White II, reads: “Innocently martyred within the coalition airstrike.”

Building initiatives on the air base completed in 2013, and it’s nonetheless in charge of the Afghan Nationwide Military.

Days after the raid, ArmorGroup employed another person to take over the staffing: White II’s brother, Gul Ahmed. They known as him Mr. White III.

In an interview, he conceded that Sadeq was his nephew however denied that his brother hosted him that night time. He stated there have been no Taliban within the village that night time.

“I misplaced my son and my relations, shut associates, and everybody,” Ahmed stated. “It’s mind-blowing.”

He added of the U.S. forces concerned within the Azizabad raid: “They may by no means settle for that they’d killed civilians.”

In 2010, the Senate Armed Providers Committee launched an inquiry into the Air Drive’s failures to offer oversight on the contract. Investigators discovered a litany of lapses and linked ArmorGroup, Pink and White II to the doomed mission.

However there have been no congressional hearings or public reckoning. G4S, ArmorGroup’s mother or father firm, was solely talked about in a footnote within the Senate report. The corporate has collected greater than $6 billion from taxpayers by means of federal contracts since 2005, in keeping with authorities knowledge.

The Afghan federal authorities sentenced Mr. Pink to dying in 2009 after he was convicted of espionage and for giving false data to U.S. forces. He appealed and is now in Bagram jail.

Pink’s son, Mirwais Khan, who was additionally as soon as a guard on the airfield, denied that his father was a spy or liable for the civilian casualties.

“We had our enemies, and our enemies accused us,” he stated in an interview. “My father was not the president, he was not a navy commander, not a corps commander to order the airstrike. The airstrike was performed and commissioned by People.”

Gul Ahmed, a village elder in Azizabad, was hired to replace his brother, White II, at the airfield. The company called him Mr. White III. In an interview, he conceded that Sadeq was his nephew but denied that his brother hosted him that night. He said there were no Taliban in the village that night.
Gul Ahmed, a village elder in Azizabad, was employed to switch his brother, White II, on the airfield. The corporate known as him Mr. White III….
Gul Ahmed, a village elder in Azizabad, was employed to switch his brother, White II, on the airfield. The corporate known as him Mr. White III. In an interview, he conceded that Sadeq was his nephew however denied that his brother hosted him that night time. He stated there have been no Taliban within the village that night time.
Brett Murphy, USA TODAY

Ackerman, the Marine assault pressure commander on the mission, is now an completed writer and columnist. He has been vocal about his service and sometimes writes concerning the human value of the wars he fought in Iraq and Afghanistan. However he has by no means spoken publicly or written about what occurred in Azizabad. 

Many of the troops who testified within the CENTCOM investigation weren’t identifiable from the interview transcripts. They largely denied that something had gone mistaken or that there had been massive numbers of civilian casualties.

Callan’s interviews ended with the identical query for a few of those that deliberate the Azizabad raid: Should you might do it once more, would you alter something? 

“No sir,” one intelligence officer responded. “I would not do something completely different.”

The workforce behind this investigation

REPORTING AND ANALYSIS:
Brett Murphy, Gina Barton, Nick Penzenstadler

EDITING:
Chris Davis, Matt Doig, Sam Roe, Brett Blackledge

GRAPHICS AND ILLUSTRATIONS:
Ramon Padilla, Kyle Slagle, Mitchell Thorson, Shawn Sullivan, Javier Zarracina, Ray Soto, Will Austin, Alex Daley-Montgomery, Alan Davies

PHOTOGRAPHY:
Jasper Colt, Chris Powers, Brett Murphy, Shahpoor Sabir

DIGITAL PRODUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT:
Spencer Holladay, Annette Meade, Ryan Hildebrandt, Dan Alegria

SOCIAL MEDIA, ENGAGEMENT AND PROMOTION:
Cara Richardson, Elizabeth Shell

More in this series

Reader's opinions

Leave a Reply


Current track

Title

Artist

Current show

Classic Showcase

10:00 am 1:00 pm

Current show

Classic Showcase

10:00 am 1:00 pm

Background