In Campaign Against Racism, Team Names Get New Scrutiny

Written by on July 10, 2020

Man Jones had been advocating for 21 lengthy years, hoping for the day when Anderson Excessive College, outdoors of Cincinnati, would drop the nickname he discovered vulgar and insulting to his Native American heritage.

A member of the Hunkpapa Lakota nation from the Standing Rock reservation in South Dakota, he and three white Anderson college students in 1999 sought to steer the varsity board to alter the nickname that “made me cringe each time I heard it.”

The college board voted down their proposal, and did so in 2003 and in 2018. However final week it lastly relented and voted to erase the identify for good, partly, Jones mentioned, due to a wave of momentum fueled by the Black Lives Matter motion.

“Issues are altering,” he mentioned, “and I’m glad they’re.”

The very subsequent day, Jones heard extra information that cheered him out of Washington, the place for years the N.F.L. crew that makes use of the identical nickname, Redskins, had vowed by no means to alter it.

However in a shock transfer, Daniel Snyder, the Washington proprietor, promised to conduct a “thorough overview” of the identify. With that, strain mounted on different groups to reply. Inside hours the Cleveland Indians vowed to have interaction with neighborhood and Native American leaders on the subject, too.

Activists have waged a protracted and, at instances, irritating marketing campaign to steer groups to alter names, logos and mascots. However immediately, after a lot resistance, a brand new willingness to rethink long-cherished names and logos on the skilled, school and highschool ranges, is giving contemporary impetus to alter crew names lengthy thought-about untouchable.

A number of the strain is coming from company sponsors like Nike and FedEx, whose request for Washington to alter the identify preceded the crew’s announcement. Amazon, Goal and Walmart have additionally moved to drop the team’s merchandise.

“It’s occurring within the context of the Black Lives Matter motion and all that means of Black folks and Indigenous folks in our nation,” mentioned Suzan Proven Harjo, a Native American activist, who has been on the forefront of the motion to alter the Washington crew’s identify. “What’s occurring proper now could be such a broad swath of society.”

PictureA meeting of the school board in Anderson Township, Ohio, in 2018 brought out supporters and opponents of the school’s mascot. The board this week dropped the name.
Credit score…Sam Greene/The Cincinnati Enquirer, by way of Related Press

As Heather Miller, the chief director of the American Indian Heart in Chicago mentioned, “That is an particularly essential second proper now.” Philip Yenyo, the chief director of the American Indian Motion of Ohio, who has been protesting the Cleveland baseball crew’s identify for nearly 30 years, added: “We have to strike whereas the iron is scorching.”

For many years, teams like these have appealed to skilled sports activities groups, schools and excessive faculties to get rid of names and logos that they are saying are dehumanizing, disrespectful and racist.

The outcomes have been blended, and resistance to alter has been fierce, aided not too long ago by President Trump, who scolded protesters in a latest tweet by saying the nicknames project strength and shouldn’t be modified.

Raymond Wooden II, a Native American and longtime Republican city councilman in Killingly, Conn., mentioned he was not offended by the Washington nickname or the identify of his hometown highschool, the Killingly Redmen.

“I doubt there was any malice in folks’s hearts once they formulated these groups and chosen the imagery that they thought would greatest characterize them,” he mentioned in a Fb message. “If there was, it backfired.”

Citing arguments like that, holdouts have resisted calls to alter, together with the Atlanta Braves, Chicago Blackhawks, and Kansas Metropolis Chiefs.

The Braves and the Blackhawks each issued statements not too long ago indicating they might not alter their names, however mentioned they deliberate to work tougher with Native American teams to advertise consciousness and respect. Additionally they reiterated the frequent chorus of groups with Native names, that they honor the heritage of these peoples.

“There’s completely no proof of that,” countered Stephanie Fryberg, a professor of psychology on the College of Michigan and a member of the Tulalip nation in Washington State. She not too long ago revealed a research displaying that about two-thirds of Native People who regularly have interaction in cultural practices are offended by the names and logos, and likewise among the habits of followers of these groups.

“While you use an individual’s identification in a sports activities area,” she mentioned, “and also you permit folks to decorate in purple face and placed on headdresses and dance and chant a Hollywood made-up tune that mocks Native custom and tradition, there is no such thing as a strategy to name that honoring.”

Most of the folks against Washington’s identify imagine it offers cowl to a bunch of school and college groups that use it, too. However Anderson’s vote might point out that’s cracking.

Within the days since Anderson’s faculty board voted, 4-1, to desert the moniker, information studies from across the nation level to different faculties contemplating dropping Native American mascots.

Greater than 2,200 excessive faculties use Native imagery of their faculty names and mascots, in response to Mascot DB, a database of crew names. That’s 600 fewer than as soon as existed — a pattern that was accelerated after a 2014 ruling by the U.S. Trademark Trial and Attraction Board that voided the Redskins trademark as “disparaging of Native People.” The ruling was later overturned.

It’s not solely Native People names and imagery that trigger offense. Some faculties make use of names and iconography celebrating the Confederacy, and with statues to Accomplice generals toppling and Mississippi taking the Accomplice bars off its state flag, faculty names may very well be subsequent.

Lee-Davis Excessive College in Mechanicsville, Va., is named the Confederates, and a neighborhood N.A.A.C.P. chapter mentioned it could revive an effort to alter the identify.

Credit score…Matt Rourke/Related Press

Avi Hopkins, a Black working again who graduated in 1994, recalled his anguish when, after scoring touchdowns, cries of, “Go Confederates,” would ring in his ears, a needling reminder that the varsity’s identify honored the pillars of the Confederacy, Robert E. Lee and Jefferson Davis.

“It actually broke me in half,” mentioned Hopkins, who later performed on the Virginia Navy Institute. “I knew that my success was bringing a constructive mild to males who negatively impacted my ancestors.”

However a lot of the momentum to alter mascots or crew names has centered on Native American references, significantly the identify the Washington crew makes use of.

It has defenders amongst faculties that use it, too.

Loudon Excessive College close to Knoxville, Tenn, is one. Jeff Harig, the soccer coach, mentioned it was initially adopted to respectfully replicate the realm’s Cherokee Nation heritage and historical past.

“I want to assume that we embody the positives of the Native American tradition,” he mentioned. “So for me personally, I hope we are able to hold the Redskins identify.”

In Bucks County, Pa., Neshaminy Excessive College additionally goes by that nickname (one in all its rivals is the Council Rock North Indians). In 2013 Donna Fann-Boyle, who’s Native American, filed a grievance with the Pennsylvania Human Relations Fee, charging that the nickname was racist and inspired dangerous behaviors on the faculty, the place her son graduated in 2016.

When she was revealed publicly as the one that filed the grievance, folks in help of the mascot threatened her and mocked her Native heritage, she mentioned. Apprehensive that the problem would overshadow her son’s senior 12 months, Ms. Fann-Boyle withdrew the grievance.

Within the present local weather, nevertheless, she hopes the varsity board could also be keen to rethink and observe the lead of Washington’s N.F.L. crew.

“Come on, the world is altering,” she mentioned of the varsity board. “What are you going to do?”

Whereas schools have been on the forefront to interchange Native American nicknames — through the years, Miami College of Ohio, Stanford, Siena and St. John’s all dropped such monikers — Florida State has held steadfastly to the identify Seminole.

It has asserted that the nickname embraces the tradition of the Seminole nation, and it has garnered the group’s blessing by, amongst different issues, providing a category on Seminole historical past and incorporating tribal designs into the trim on their jerseys.

San Diego State College has slow-walked away from Indigenous iconography during the last 20 years — all whereas clinging to its Aztecs nickname.

“There’s no face portray, we don’t permit the tomahawk chop,” mentioned Ramona Perez, an anthropology professor at San Diego State, who has not taken a place on the nickname.

However Ozzie Monge, a former San Diego State lecturer who led an unsuccessful marketing campaign to alter the identify, urged the varsity was reluctant to tamper a lot with the branding of groups.

“There’s one reply why they haven’t modified it,” he mentioned. ”Sports activities.”

Reader's opinions

Leave a Reply

Current track



Current show


3:00 pm 5:00 pm

Current show


3:00 pm 5:00 pm