Inside the NFL owners meeting: White coaches challenge owners on league’s diversity woes

Written by on October 17, 2022

USA TODAY Sports activities investigates: Elevating range throughout NFL teaching staffs

USA TODAY Sports activities investigates the place range is missing in NFL teaching workers throughout the league, and why it issues.


One after the other, Pete Carroll, John Harbaugh, Frank Reich and Andy Reid addressed the NFL house owners at this 12 months’s annual league assembly, advocating for Black coaches on their staffs now and people they’ve crossed paths with throughout their prolonged careers.

They vouched for the talents of those coaches who’re routinely handed by for the NFL’s high jobs, praising their abilities and management qualities.

These white head coaches, among the most distinguished within the recreation at present, spoke of the affect Black coaches have had on them and of their locker rooms, attempting to make house owners acknowledge what they’d discover if they’d solely look past the colour of those coaches’ pores and skin.

Their ardour was clear, as was their sense of urgency, with Carroll at one level primarily asking house owners what was fallacious with them.

“Possibly some individuals didn’t like what was mentioned. While you open the ground, you get such a honesty,” Pittsburgh Steelers proprietor Artwork Rooney II advised USA TODAY Sports activities.

“There have been some issues mentioned that house owners wouldn’t agree with.”

EXPLORE: Which NFL teams have the most diverse coaching staffs?

NFL COACHES PROJECT: USA TODAY Sports compiled and analyzed demographic data for NFL coaches at every level

Pittsburgh Steelers coach Mike Tomlin was the youngest head coach ever to win a championship. Steelers owner Art Rooney II took over ownership of the team in 2017 following the death of his father, Dan.
Pittsburgh Steelers coach Mike Tomlin was the youngest head coach ever to win a championship. Steelers proprietor Artwork Rooney II took over possession of the group in 2017 following the loss of life of his father, Dan.
Chuck Cook dinner, USA TODAY Sports activities

Conversations on the annual assembly, also referred to as the NFL house owners assembly, hardly ever develop into public, and Rooney didn’t wish to go into in depth element as a result of what’s mentioned there may be supposed to remain personal. Carroll and Reid additionally declined to touch upon what they mentioned to house owners.

However but another hiring cycle had ended with the NFL no more diverse in its most high-profile positions than it was 20 years in the past. Former Miami Dolphins coach Brian Flores had sued the league and some of its teams for racial discrimination, accusing the NFL of lip service in its sincerity to offering alternatives for minority coaches. 

Staying silent was not an possibility. 

“We have been talking from our hearts. And what that was, was, `Pay attention, we have to see some outcomes,’” Reich advised USA TODAY Sports activities final month. “We’ve bought a whole lot of good individuals, nice house owners, nice house owners who’re nice human beings they usually’re nice businessmen. We’re all attempting to perform the identical factor, to make the NFL one of the best league and take advantage of influence in society. We’ve a platform that may do this.

“If we’re going to have a platform, to have the best sports activities group on this planet, we have to do higher at among the range points in relation to teaching.”

WHAT WE LEARNED: Four key findings from USA TODAY’s analysis of NFL coaches

GRAPHIC NOVEL: A brief history of Black NFL coaches

The NFL adopted the Rooney Rule, named for Artwork Rooney’s late father, Dan, in hopes it might enhance the variety of Black coaches in a league the place greater than two-thirds of the gamers are Black. It initially required groups to interview not less than one minority candidate for any head teaching job, and has since been expanded to incorporate coordinators, quarterbacks coaches and senior-level entrance workplace positions. Groups should additionally now interview not less than two various candidates for any head coach openings.

But of the 10 openings within the 32-team league this final offseason, solely two have been crammed by Black coaches. That gave the NFL three Black head coaches when the season began, the identical quantity as when the Rooney Rule was applied in 2003. Steve Wilks makes it 4 now, having been named interim head coach of the Carolina Panthers after they fired Matt Rhule final week.

WHAT’S IN IT FOR INTERIMS?: Carolina’s Steve Wilks latest Black coach thrust into challenging role

The Carolina Panthers named Steve Wilks interim head coach ahead of Week 6, stepping in after the team fired Matt Rhule.
The Carolina Panthers named Steve Wilks interim head coach forward of Week 6, stepping in after the group fired Matt Rhule.
Bob Donnan, Bob Donnan-USA TODAY Sports activities

Three different groups are additionally headed by males of shade; Robert Saleh, who’s of Lebanese descent, coaches the New York Jets; Mike McDaniel, who’s biracial, is the Miami Dolphins’ coach; and Ron Rivera, who’s Hispanic, leads the Washington Commanders.

This isn’t an anomaly.

Of the 72 head coaches employed within the final decade, just 14 have been men of color. In a league the place traditionally about two-thirds of the gamers are Black, there has by no means been greater than eight non-white coaches in a single season. That quantity was reached in 2011 and 2017.

“We’ve seen progress on a variety of fronts,” mentioned Rooney, who chairs the NFL’s Range, Fairness and Inclusion Committee. “There are extra Black normal managers than we’ve ever had. We’re hoping that progress strikes to the top coaches.”

However the white coaches who spoke on the house owners assembly, held the final weekend in March in Palm Seashore, Florida, are bored with progress that’s incremental at greatest.

Troy Vincent, the NFL’s govt vice chairman of soccer operations, mentioned white coaches, akin to Carroll, Reid and Reich, usually come to him with names of Black and brown coaches who can be good candidates for promotion. However that is essentially the most vocal Vincent mentioned he can keep in mind the coaches being as a collective. 

And for somebody who’s been on the entrance traces of attempting to enhance range within the NFL, seeing white coaches foyer house owners on behalf of Black coaches who’ve did not advance due to systemic racism was heartening.

“I bought very emotional listening as a result of it was such a breath of recent air,” Vincent advised USA TODAY Sports activities final month, including he needed to flip his head to the aspect whereas the coaches spoke. “These males are keen about what they do, they usually converse very, very extremely of people which have touched their lives or impacted their lives.

“In that specific room, to be brave — as a result of that is what it takes to do this and to place it on the road — it was refreshing. It was refreshing to see and listen to.”

‘DIDN’T LOOK THE PART’: The reasons Black coaches don’t get NFL head coaching jobs

Troy Vincent, the NFL's executive vice president of football operations, has been on the front lines of trying to improve diversity in the NFL.
Troy Vincent, the NFL’s govt vice chairman of soccer operations, has been on the entrance traces of attempting to enhance range within the NFL.
The Related Press

And it wasn’t simply the coaches, Vincent mentioned. Some group executives chimed in, together with Chris Ballard, Howie Roseman and John Lynch, normal managers of the Colts, Philadelphia Eagles and San Francisco 49ers, respectively.

Some house owners spoke, too, vouching for the individuals of shade they’ve employed.

“In that setting it is easy to be silent. However these males, they spoke,” Vincent mentioned.

Reich was fast to say the main focus shouldn’t be on him and the opposite white coaches, that they solely mentioned what they really feel is correct. However it’s also a deeply private subject for them, as a result of they know the character of the boys and high quality of the coaches who usually are not being employed due to systemic racism.

Reid advised the house owners somebody wanted to rent his offensive coordinator, Eric Bieniemy, echoing what he has usually mentioned publicly. Bieniemy has performed a giant function within the growth of Patrick Mahomes, who received each a Tremendous Bowl and NFL MVP honors in his first two seasons as a starter, however has not gotten a head teaching job regardless of being thought of by a number of groups every of the final 4 years. 

Reich bought his first teaching job with Tony Dungy in Indianapolis and, after Dungy retired, labored for Jim Caldwell.

“This subject is absolutely necessary to them and due to my love and respect for them, this subject is absolutely necessary to me,” Reich mentioned. “It’s one factor to say, `Yeah, I agree this is a crucial subject,’ nevertheless it’s one other factor to truly attempt to take steps to attempt to assist.”

Coaches are given time to handle the house owners at each annual assembly, permitting them to lift considerations. At this 12 months’s assembly, house owners additionally needed to know what coaches considered increasing the Rooney Rule once more to require each team to hire a minority offensive assistant who will work carefully with the top coach, offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach.

It has since been adopted.

Reich mentioned he thinks the brand new rule will assist, as a result of it would give coaches of shade entrée to the positions that not too long ago have been a springboard to move teaching jobs. However Reich mentioned he additionally hopes house owners notice one of the best coaches usually are not essentially “offensive gurus,” however those that are one of the best leaders.

“I used to be one of many guys within the locker room,” mentioned Reich, who spent 13 seasons within the NFL as a backup quarterback. “What guys within the locker room need is a pacesetter of males. I feel that’s bought to be a extra central a part of the main focus. I feel that’ll open it as much as extra individuals.”

Indianapolis Colts head coach Frank Reich was part of the group of white coaches who addressed the NFL owners at this year’s annual league meeting, advocating for Black coaches on their staffs.
Indianapolis Colts head coach Frank Reich was a part of the group of white coaches who addressed the NFL house owners at this 12 months’s annual league assembly, advocating for Black coaches on their staffs.
Jenna Watson/IndyStar

Reich mentioned the house owners he is aware of are well-intended, and he spoke of the satisfaction he feels in working for somebody like Colts proprietor Jim Irsay, who has been one of many extra proactive house owners in relation to range. 

However a disconnect stays between what house owners say they need and what they do, and that’s what Reich and his fellow coaches have been attempting to make plain. 

“It’s a tough subject,” Reich mentioned. “We’ve to be intentional. I feel we’re in some methods. I feel we’re all simply saying, we will do higher. Not solely can we do higher, however we have to see some outcomes. The NFL is a results-driven league. If that’s the case, we have to see some outcomes on this space as effectively.

“For all of the sources we have now, and for all the great women and men which might be on this league — and I actually imagine that — one thing is lacking. As a result of we’re not seeing the outcomes we must always see in areas of management within the league.

“We have to see extra progress.”

USA TODAY Sports activities reporters Tom Schad and Chris Bumbaca contributed to this report.

Reader's opinions

Leave a Reply

Current track



Current show


1:00 pm 2:00 pm

Current show


1:00 pm 2:00 pm