Some House progressives aren't happy with Senate version of COVID relief package. Here's what changed.

Written by on March 6, 2021


The $1.9 trillion COVID-19 reduction invoice had been the topic of bitter bipartisan arguments. Wochit

The Senate passed President Joe Biden’s $1.9 trillion COVID-19 relief plan Saturday after a marathon debate that went on for greater than 24 hours straight as a slew of amendments to the Home model of the invoice have been proposed and, in some instances, adopted. 

Some Home Democrats are already griping over the modifications made to the laws – significantly the elimination of a federal minimal wage hike – earlier than the invoice comes again to their chamber for a vote as quickly as Tuesday. However these peeved progressives seem poised to put aside their misgivings and approve the Senate modifications. 

“Even if we imagine any weakening of the Home provisions have been dangerous coverage and dangerous politics, the truth is that the ultimate amendments have been comparatively minor concessions,” Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-Wash., the congressional Progressive Caucus chair, stated in an announcement Saturday.

Help from progressives will probably be crucial as a result of, with no Republicans on board, Home Democrats can solely afford to lose 5 votes and nonetheless go the invoice. Two Democrats voted in opposition to the Home’s model of the invoice when it handed final week. 

Because the Senate modified the Home invoice, Rep. Bonnie Watson Coleman, D-N.J., shared her disdain for the modifications on Twitter Friday and questioned whether or not she may vote for the ultimate package deal.

“This pattern is outrageous,” Watson Coleman tweeted, itemizing among the Senate’s modifications. “What are we doing right here? I am frankly disgusted with a few of my colleagues and query whether or not I can help this invoice.”

Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., and Ilhan Omar, D-Minn. – two outstanding progressive congresswomen – appeared to agree with their colleague by sharing her Friday evening tweet.

Dwell stimulus updates: Biden praises Senate passage of $1.9 trillion COVID relief plan as ‘giant step forward’

Watson Coleman informed USA TODAY in a subsequent cellphone interview she was “pondering very exhausting about making an announcement” when the invoice got here up for a Home vote. 

“As progressives,” she stated, “we’ll have to determine the place the road within the sand is” and what number of extra concessions they’d make to reasonable Democrats.

Home Democratic management, nevertheless, is assured they may go the invoice. After the invoice handed the Senate, Home Majority Chief Steny Hoyer, D-Md., introduced a Tuesday vote and stated they’d be capable of “ship this invoice to President Biden for his signature early subsequent week.”

Listed here are the modifications between the 2 variations of the invoice:

$15 federal minimal wage eliminated

A federal hourly minimal wage enhance was included within the model of the reduction invoice that was authorised by the Home; nevertheless, it was stripped from the Senate model after the Senate parliamentarian discovered it to be in opposition to finances guidelines.

Senate Democrats’ try to reinsert a $15 minimal wage provision Friday additionally failed when eight Democratic caucus members voted with all Senate Republicans in opposition to Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders’ proposal.

Even when the parliamentarian had not dominated in opposition to it, the minimal wage enhance didn’t seem to have the help it wanted to go the Senate. Democratic Sens. Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona and Joe Manchin of West Virginia have each been vocal about not supporting a federal minimal wage enhance.

Regardless of the federal minimal wage enhance being reduce from the package deal and his personal misgivings on the invoice, Sanders nonetheless voted for the Senate’s COVID reduction package deal.

Fewer folks get $1,400 

Just like the Home model, the Senate invoice consists of $1,400 stimulus checks to People nevertheless it lowered the earnings eligibility for taxpayers getting the funds. 

Below the Home invoice, stimulus checks would section out for people making between $75,000-$100,000 a 12 months and {couples} making $150,000-$200,000. Below the Senate invoice, the section out stops at $80,000 for people and $160,000 for {couples}.

Roughly Eight million fewer households will get a verify below the Senate invoice in contrast with what the Home handed, in keeping with an evaluation from the Tax Coverage Middle.

Unemployment advantages diminished

Though each the Senate and Home handed direct funds and unemployment advantages provisions, the Senate amended each provisions throughout their debate after voting on the reduction invoice was stalled for a number of hours.

The Home invoice prolonged federal unemployment advantages till Aug. 29 and elevated that help to $400 per week. That’s on high of what beneficiaries are getting via their state unemployment insurance coverage program.

The Senate invoice would prolong the improved unemployment advantages via Sept. 6 at $300 per week. Additionally, the primary $10,200 of advantages would non-taxable. The availability applies to households with incomes below $150,000.

CA subway, NY bridge tasks nixed

The Senate dropped two contentious provisions from the Home invoice that Republicans had derided as wasteful, pork-barrel spending for the Democratic strongholds of California and New York. 

The 2 tasks have been the enlargement of the Bay Space subway system, BART, and the development of a bridge between upstate New York and Canada. 

“That is the way in which Nancy Pelosi will get $140 million for her tunnel of affection to Silicon Valley,” Sen. John Barrasso, R-Wyo, stated Tuesday of the BART provision.

 The bridge connecting Canada and New York had initially been part of a funding request by then-Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao below the Trump administration.

“Now that the 2 tasks that Republicans misled the general public about within the Home invoice have been eliminated, it’s unclear how Republicans will justify their opposition to the American Rescue Plan, which has robust bipartisan help among the many public,” Home Speaker Nancy Pelosi spokesman Drew Hammill stated after these provisions have been scrapped.

Extra: San Francisco transit money, NY bridge scrapped from COVID-19 bill amid GOP complaints

Limits on help for state and native authorities

The Senate offers $350 billion for state and native authorities, which is similar because the Home model, however provides the stipulation that the cash can solely cowl prices incurred by the top of 2024. And the cash can’t be used to offset tax cuts or create a pension fund.

One other stipulation of the Senate invoice requires that small states get a minimum of the identical quantity that they acquired below the final COVID reduction package deal from final March.

States may also obtain $10 billion below a brand new Vital Infrastructure Tasks program that will assist states, territories and tribal governments perform capital tasks.

Funding for the Financial Growth Administration elevated to $750 million below the Senate invoice. That cash is meant to go to communities harm by job and income loss associated to the decline in tourism, journey and outside recreation.

Well being care help

Below a legislation often called COBRA, those that lose their jobs can stay on their firm’s well being care plan for as much as 18 months however they often nonetheless should pay their full month-to-month premium. The Senate’s invoice will subsidize 100% of these premiums below COBRA via the top of September to make sure laid-off employees can maintain their medical insurance.  

Whereas the Home additionally included provisions to subsidize medical insurance premiums, they have been capped at 85% of the price.

The Senate additionally included $8.5 billion for the Supplier Aid Program to assist struggling well being care suppliers in rural areas which have but to obtain their share of COVID-19 reduction.

Extra help

The Senate additionally authorised $510 million greater than the Home to fund FEMA’s Emergency Meals and Shelter Program, which offers help to homeless service suppliers for in a single day shelter, meals, meals banks and pantries throughout the nation.

The extra funding may also present one month’s hire or mortgage fee to assist stop evictions, in addition to a month’s utility funds to stop service cut-offs.

And the Senate invoice offers Amtrak and the USA Digital Service with an extra $200 million on high of what the Home handed for reduction funding.

The elevated funding for the USDS will assist meet the excessive demand from completely different companies that want assist offering companies, together with vaccine distribution, unemployment help and stimulus checks.

Contributing: The Related Press 


Present Thumbnails

Present Captions

Learn or Share this story:

Reader's opinions

Leave a Reply

Current track



Current show

Notorious In The Morning

6:30 am 11:00 am

Current show

Notorious In The Morning

6:30 am 11:00 am