The US is ailing: Lancet Commission blasts Donald Trump's 'inept and insufficient' COVID-19 response, laments widening inequalities

Written by on February 11, 2021


President Joe Biden is taking his first steps to reverse Trump administration well being care insurance policies. Chatting with reporters within the Oval Workplace, Biden stated he was signing two govt orders to “undo the injury Trump has carried out” to well being care. (Jan. 28) AP Home

About 40% of the nation’s coronavirus deaths may have been prevented if the US’ common dying fee matched different industrialized nations, a brand new Lancet Fee report discovered. 

Whereas the Lancet Fee on Public Coverage and Well being within the Trump period faulted former President Donald Trump’s “inept and inadequate” response to COVID-19, its report stated roots of the nation’s poor well being outcomes are a lot deeper.

Fee co-chairs Dr. Steffie Woolhandler and Dr. David Himmelstein, professors on the Metropolis College of New York’s Hunter School and longtime advocates for a single-payer well being system akin to Medicare for All, stated the report revealed Thursday underscores a long time of health, economic and social policies that have accelerated the nation’s disparities.

The report discovered U.S. life expectancy started trailing different industrialized nations 4 a long time in the past. In 2018, two years earlier than the pandemic, the report stated 461,00zero fewer Individuals would have died if U.S. mortality charges matched different Group of Seven nations: Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan and the UK.  

‘Onerous truths and necessary info’: Biden pushes for coronavirus testing reset with $50 billion plan

“The overriding factor that we have to do in our nation is to lower the massive and widening inequalities which have emerged in our nation,” Himmelstein stated.

COVID-19 has disproportionately affected folks of coloration with the dying charges amongst Blacks growing 50% in comparison with whites. Coronavirus deaths for folks of coloration are 1.2 to three.6 occasions greater than for whites; the disparities had been particularly excessive amongst middle-aged adults, presumably an indication of crowded residing circumstances and jobs that didn’t enable folks to securely distance, the report stated. 

Public well being measures akin to masks carrying and bodily distancing may have saved lives, Woolhandler stated, however Trump did not create a nationwide response, as a substitute leaving essential selections to states.

His actions “brought on numerous residents to fail to take it significantly and interfered with the type of coordinated response they’ve been ready to make use of in numerous nations which are extra profitable than the U.S. in controlling the epidemic,”  Woolhandler stated.

Along with response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the report stated Trump weakened the Reasonably priced Care Act and 2.three million extra Individuals grew to become uninsured, a determine that doesn’t embody those that misplaced employer-provided protection in the course of the pandemic.

‘The worst attainable time’: HHS gives cold shoulder to victims of common vaccine injury

The fee took goal at Republicans and Democrats alike. The election of Ronald Reagan in 1980 marked the tip of the New Deal and civil rights period in favor of “neoliberal insurance policies” that eroded social packages, the report stated. The report assailed Democrat Invoice Clinton’s assist for tightening welfare eligibility and signing a federal crime invoice that led to “mass incarceration,” disproportionately harming Latinos and Black males.

Personal insurers’ charged “exorbitant overhead and earnings” when extending government-subsidized protection to lower- and middle-income Individuals underneath former President Barack Obama’s signature well being care regulation, the report stated.

The fee instructed an extended record of govt orders and legislative actions to reverse traits negatively affecting the well being of Individuals. Among the many fixes: Undertake a single-payer well being system akin to Medicare for All, championed by Sen. Bernie Sanders throughout his unsuccessful run for the Democratic Social gathering’s presidential nomination. 

“We’re nonetheless in a really deep gap. We now have 30 million uninsured folks. We now have tens of tens of millions of extra who’re underinsured,” stated Woolhandler. “The factor that might be greatest for the well being of the inhabitants could be Medicare for All.”

The fee’s want record goes past medical care to incorporate progressives beliefs such because the Inexperienced New Deal, felony justice reform, repealing Trump’s 2017 tax cuts and mountaineering spending on social packages to the degrees of six different industrialized nations.

Woolhandler and Himmelstein are co-founders of Physicians for a Nationwide Well being Program, which advocates for a single-payer well being system. 

Biden has rejected Medicare for All and as a substitute needs to bolster the Reasonably priced Care Act with extra profitable subsidies for low- and middle-income earners. Home Democrats unveiled a bill this week that might increase tax-credit subsidies for Individuals who buy market plans. Biden already signed an executive order to reopen enrollment on from Feb. 15 by means of Might 15.

In 2019, the Urban Institute estimated adopting a single-payer system akin to Medicare for All would improve federal spending by $34 trillion over 10 years. The assume tank has not up to date the research, however City Institute Well being Coverage Middle fellow and economist Linda Blumberg stated well being care spending will increase every year. 

Monitoring COVID-19 vaccine distribution by state: How many people have been vaccinated in the US?

Such an formidable overhaul additionally would doubtless have to be gradual to reduce disruption to hospitals, medical doctors and sufferers. “If you happen to had been going to do it responsibly and also you had been going to part it in over a time frame, that really makes it price extra money,” Blumberg stated. 

The fee stated a single-payer system would save $626 billion every year on medical billing and administrative prices. Whereas the report didn’t say how a lot Medicare for All would price, it cited a study that found 20 of 22 models predicted whole well being spending could be much less underneath a single-payer system. 

In December, the Congressional Budget Office reported a single-payer plan would improve federal spending from $1.5 to $three trillion in 2030 over projected ranges. Nevertheless, whole private and non-private health-care spending may vary from financial savings of $700 billion to a rise price of $300 billion. The extra optimistic state of affairs counts on administrative financial savings and well being suppliers agreeing to decrease funds.

“A Medicare for All program would considerably improve financial equality,” Himmelstein stated. “Poor folks spend a a lot bigger share of their incomes for his or her well being care although they get a lot much less for his or her well being care.”

Ken Alltucker is on Twitter at @kalltucker, or could be emailed at


Present Thumbnails

Present Captions

Learn or Share this story: being/2021/02/11/lancet-commission-donald-trump-covid-19-health-medicare-for-all/4453762001/

Reader's opinions

Leave a Reply

Current track



Current show


11:00 am 2:00 pm

Current show


11:00 am 2:00 pm