'Tribalism is a hell of a drug.' Trump impeachment trial reopens GOP battle lines even as he is acquitted

Written by on February 14, 2021


Rep. Jamie Raskin tells reporters that he’s assured within the case Home impeachment managers made towards former President Trump, regardless of acquittal. USA TODAY

WASHINGTON – Hours earlier than Senate Republicans acquitted Donald Trump in his second impeachment trial, a GOP Home member practically knocked if off monitor.

Senate Republicans needed to beat again last-minute Democrat calls for to name witnesses after Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler, R-Wash.– who had backed impeachment – mentioned  Home Minority Chief Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., instructed her Trump had dismissed pleas for assist as his supporters ransacked the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6.

The decision for witnesses failed, however it did not take lengthy for Herrera Beutler to develop into a goal of Trump’s supporters. 

“The reward that retains on giving to the Democrats … The Trump loyal 75 million are watching,” tweeted freshman Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., a fierce Trump loyalist.

The backwards and forwards underscored the interior battle amongst Republicans, between those that need to proceed following Trump and those that consider the get together wants to maneuver past a disgraced ex-president to win elections sooner or later.

Extra: Trump acquitted, confusion over witnesses: Top takeaways from impeachment trial’s last day

A 57-43 majority of the Senate voted to convict Trump, however fell in need of the two-thirds majority required for conviction. Seven Republicans joined the 50 Democrats – greater than anticipated. Final yr, when Trump was acquitted over his dealings with Ukraine, just one Republican, Sen. Mitt Romney, R-Utah, joined Democrats voting to convict.

“Tribalism is a hell of a drug, however our oath to the Structure means we’re constrained to the information,” Sen. Ben Sasse, R-Neb., mentioned. 

And although Senate Minority Chief Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., voted to acquit, he gave a searing assertion on the Senate flooring, saying Trump is “virtually and morally accountable” for the Jan. 6 riot.

In a press release after the acquittal, Trump was undeterred, saying his motion “has only just begun.”

“Within the months forward I’ve a lot to share with you, and I look ahead to persevering with our unimaginable journey collectively to realize American greatness for all of our folks,” Trump mentioned. “We now have a lot work forward of us, and shortly we’ll emerge with a imaginative and prescient for a brilliant, radiant, and limitless American future.”

The aftermath of the impeachment trial, which featured intense movies of the violent assault on the U.S. Capitol, units up years of Republican main battles between pro-Trump and anti-Trump forces, dividing the get together because it tries to reclaim management of Congress in 2022 and the White Home in 2024.

Extra: How Donald Trump will be remembered after four tumultuous years as president

Extra: Risky business: Donald Trump isn’t alone in seeing his political fate tied to his impeachment trial

“This impeachment vote goes to additional rend the Republican Social gathering,” mentioned Lara Brown, director of the Graduate Faculty of Political Administration at George Washington College. Republicans discuss a “large tent,” she mentioned, however “unity won’t doubtless be potential as a result of no significant gray space exists” between Trump’s followers and different Republicans. 

“Evidently the get together is headed for a lot of extra months of in-fighting that may solely be resolved by the 2022 elections, main and common elections,” she mentioned. “And by resolved, I imply that one faction will doubtless prevail over the opposite, however which can win is tough to say.”

Trump 2024? Different Republicans are making strikes, too

Trump, who stayed silent in the course of the Senate impeachment trial, has not mentioned whether he will run again in 2024 however his acquittal in leaves him free to take action.

Republicans who’re contemplating their very own presidential candidacies – like Sens. Ted Cruz, Josh Hawley, Marco Rubio and Rand Paul – didn’t even think about conviction within the impeachment trial. They voted towards holding the trial in any respect, saying the Senate lacked the constitutional authority to strive somebody who is just not on workplace any longer. 

“This can be a political impeachment,” Cruz tweeted in the course of the trial.

One other potential Republican presidential candidate, former South Carolina governor Nikki Haley, is searching for distance from the impeached president.


Present Thumbnails

Present Captions

Haley, the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations below Trump till 2018, instructed Politico she expects Trump is “going to search out himself additional and additional remoted,” and does not suppose he’ll run for president once more: “I feel he’s misplaced any type of political viability he was going to have.”

Nonetheless, different potential candidates have chosen to play into Trump’s grievances post-election. Cruz and Hawley went as far as to object to the counting of Electoral School votes due to Trump’s unfounded protests that the election was stolen from him.

Congress was debating that difficulty when the insurrectionists broke into the U.S. Capitol Jan. 6.

Extra: Chaos, confusion and anger: What you couldn’t see on the Senate floor

Rubio, who engaged with Trump in a sequence of brawls in the course of the 2016 Republican presidential main, has additionally been extra supportive of late. Rubio additionally doubtless has seen studies that Ivanka Trump – Trump’s daughter and former White Home advisor, who lately moved to Florida – could run for his Senate seat subsequent yr.

Whereas Rubio has had his share of disagreements with Trump, the Florida senator mentioned earlier than the impeachment trial that it was “conceited” for opponents to hunt the ex-president’s disqualification from workplace.

Trump’s maintain on the get together at this level is just not absolute, nonetheless. There’s proof that the riot, the impeachment, and the trial – and the photographs of Trump supporters roaming the halls, threatening lawmakers – is draining Republican assist for Trump. 

When the Home voted in January to question Trump, some Republicans noticed the Senate trial as an opportunity to rid themselves of the previous president’s political affect. Ten Home Republicans did vote to question Trump, greater than his earlier impeachment in 2020. 

Nonetheless, Jennifer Mercieca, an affiliate professor of communication at Texas A&M College, mentioned “acquittal implies that it is nonetheless Trump’s get together, for higher or for worse, and certain for worse.”

Mercieca, writer of “Demagogue for President: The Rhetorical Genius of Donald Trump,” mentioned the trial gave Republicans the prospect “to reject Trump and Trumpism.” As an alternative, many get together members embraced him, she mentioned, maybe to the get together’s detriment long run.


Lead Home Impeachment Supervisor Jamie Raskin argues within the Senate trial of Donald Trump that there is no such thing as a First Modification protection towards the impeachment cost. “The First Modification doesn’t create some superpower immunity,” Raskin mentioned. (Feb. 11) AP Home

The primary subsequent step: Trump and the 2022 elections 

With the impeachment trial behind him, Trump is anticipated to first check his energy amongst Republicans in upcoming congressional and state elections – together with divisive Republican primaries.

Trump and his supporters have vowed to again main challengers towards Republicans who supported impeachment, significantly the Home Republicans who voted for it.

That focus on checklist ranges from Rep. Liz Cheney, the Home’s third-ranked Republican, to Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp and Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, each of whom rejected Trump’s calls for to reverse the election outcomes.

Extra: Impeachment trial puts Trump back in the spotlight. That might not be a good thing for him.

Extra: Donald Trump is unhappy with his legal team, allies say, but still confident he’ll be acquitted

However difficult primaries do not all the time translate to losses. 

The Trump issue may damage Republicans generally elections in states and congressional districts which can be carefully divided among the many GOP, Democrats, and independents.

Trump is “nonetheless the 800-pound gorilla throughout the GOP,” Luntz mentioned, “however he has no assist outdoors the get together.” Republicans will want these sorts of voters to win sufficient Home and Senate races to reclaim Congress.

And Republicans who oppose Trump are getting ready to marketing campaign for individuals who consider the get together wants to maneuver on from the impeached president.

Rep. Adam Kinzinger, R-In poor health., who voted for impeachment and has created a brand new political motion committee, instructed CNN that “I do not worry the President in any respect.”

A number of unknowns may issue into Republicans’ future

There are a lot of months earlier than the 2022 congressional elections and the 2024 presidential election. And a number of other excellent points may issue into each elections, together with probably extra authorized hassle for Trump.

Prosecutors in New York are investigating Trump over previous monetary actions. The district attorney’s office in Atlanta is investigating whether or not Trump broke the legislation when he pressured Raffensberger to “discover” sufficient votes to overturn his election loss to Biden in that state.

The previous president additionally turns 78 years outdated in 2024, although that’s the identical age Biden is now. Biden grew to become the oldest president ever inaugurated when he took the oath in January.

Through the impeachment trial, Home Democratic prosecutors mentioned failing to carry Trump accountable could encourage him and his supporters to assault establishments once more, maybe in a future marketing campaign.

Rep. Ted Lieu, D-Calif., instructed senators he’s “not afraid of Donald Trump operating once more in 4 years.” Quite, “I’m afraid he’ll run once more and lose,” Lieu mentioned. “As a result of he can do that once more.”

One other unknown is whether or not Trump supporters can discover credible candidates to problem pro-impeachment Republicans.


Attorneys for Donald Trump opened his impeachment protection by strenuously denying he performed any function in inciting the lethal riot on the Capitol, blasting the case towards him as political vengeance and a part of a yearslong Democratic “witch hunt.” (Feb. 12) AP Home

Republican strategist Alex Conant, who labored for Rubio’s presidential candidate in 2016, mentioned he doubts Trump will likely be very influential in 2022 and past. Most voters, he mentioned, will regularly draw back from the ex-president.

“It’s going to take time for the get together to maneuver on,” Conant mentioned. “What occurred on Jan. 6 was actually dangerous for the Republican model. It’s going to take time to recuperate from that.”

Up to now, Trump and his allies have a combined report on the subject of hurting pro-impeachment Republicans.

They failed in their attempt to have Cheney removed from her post as Home Republican Convention chairwoman. However in the identical assembly, Republicans refused to punish pro-Trump Rep. Taylor Greene, R-Ga., over her social media posts about conspiracy theories and threats to political opponents.

Going through the prospect of divisive primaries, a number of political analysts famous that each Trump backers and Trump opponents have mentioned the thought of a 3rd political get together, a growth that might additional cut up the get together.

Jack Pitney, professor of presidency at Claremont McKenna School in California, mentioned most GOP voters nonetheless seem supportive of Trump. “As lengthy as Republican voters stick with Trump,” he mentioned, “so will most Republican leaders.”

The writer of “Un-American: The Pretend Patriotism of Donald J. Trump,” Pitney illustrated the Republicans’ downside by re-working the lyrics of a Pete Seeger protest track concerning the Vietnam Battle.

“The get together is waist deep within the Large Muddy,” he mentioned. “and the bottom says to push on.”

Learn or Share this story: https://www.usatoday.com/story/information/politics/2021/02/13/trump-impeachment-trial-reignites-gop-battle-even-he-acquitted/6738664002/

Reader's opinions

Leave a Reply

Current track



Current show

Full Throttle Radio

9:00 pm 12:00 am

Current show

Full Throttle Radio

9:00 pm 12:00 am