'Very threatening' for LGBTQ community: Same-sex marriage defendant, plaintiff join forces to oppose Amy Coney Barrett's nomination

Written by on October 20, 2020


LGBTQ rights have come a great distance within the U.S. However the neighborhood nonetheless faces threats within the type of legalization, discrimination and even violence. USA TODAY

Two names can be remembered as on opposing sides within the case that made same-sex marriage equality the law of the land.

However to one another, they’re simply Jim and Rick.

Jim Obergefell grew to become a civil rights activist after the landmark 2015 case bearing his title because the plaintiff. He and the person on the opposite facet of the v, Richard Hodges, former director of the Ohio Division of Well being, have developed a friendship.

“It’s awfully enjoyable to shock folks after they discover out we’re mates,” Obergefell mentioned.

Extra stunning: They share “the identical dedication to equal rights for all,” Hodges mentioned.

The 2 litigants teamed up at a press convention for Household Equality, a company advocating for LGBTQ households. This time, they’d an pressing message: That the affirmation of Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court docket is rushed – and it is “very threatening” to the LGBTQ neighborhood.

Though they’ve beforehand mentioned their experiences with the landmark case and their ensuing friendship, earlier than this week the 2 had by no means actively lobbied for a trigger collectively.

However Barrett’s affirmation threatens the very rights he fought for, Obergefell mentioned, and it was time to talk up.   

“The concern may be very actual” that marriage rightscould be dismantled, Obergefell mentioned in an unique interview with USA TODAY earlier than a press convention saying their opposition to Barrett’s nomination. It’s “very reasonable for us to be involved about what might occur to our proper to marry or our households.”

Hodges instructed USA TODAY that within the 2015 case he had an obligation to defend the Ohio structure, which barred his company from acknowledging same-sex married {couples}.

However the protection of equal rights “is a trigger price preventing for,” he mentioned, and he helps marriage equality.

Of larger concern to him, nevertheless, is that the Senate “cannot come collectively to guard people who find themselves affected by the coronavirus, however we will push a Supreme Court docket nominee by means of in document time.”

Just lately, the Supreme Court docket has defended the development of LGBTQ rights. However Obergefell worries that Barrett’s affirmation might change that.

Barrett, President Donald Trump’s pick to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, has given lectures to Alliance Defending Freedom, which the Southern Poverty Regulation Middle has designated as an anti-LGBTQ hate group. Twenty-seven LGBTQ organizations opposed her affirmation to the Seventh Circuit Court docket of Appeals in 2017.

Supreme Court docket justicesset stage to end marriage equality

Obergefell pointed to Barrett’s questioning of whether or not key civil rights protections embrace LGBTQ People.

At a 2016 lecture at Jacksonville College, Barrett mentioned it could “pressure” the textual content of Title IX to permit transgender folks to make use of public restrooms that match their genders, categorizing trans ladies as “males.”

The Supreme Court ruled in June that that very same regulation, which bars intercourse discrimination within the office, applies to homosexual, lesbian and transgender employees.

Whereas Obergefell does not suppose that marriage equality legalization can be reversed within the court docket, he worries that Barrett’s nomination will imply the “rights and tasks” that include marriage could possibly be chipped away.

This disintegration might imply “additional erosion of protections in employment, schooling, housing, credit score and extra” for the LGBTQ neighborhood, he mentioned.

A part of that erosion: the overturn of the Reasonably priced Care Act.

About 65% of LGBTQ American have preexisting circumstances, Obergefell mentioned, in contrast with 50% of People total. Barrett has made clear that she opposes the ACA, he mentioned, which might imply the gutting of a authorities service that helps shield the LGBTQ neighborhood from discrimination in well being care.

Hodges mentioned Obergefell‘s reversal might result in a “patchwork of rights relying on the state.”

In separate interviews, he and Obergefell used the identical label to explain the undermining of the establishment of marriage for LGBTQ folks.

“We weren’t preventing for ‘skim-milk marriages’, as Ruth Bader Ginsburg calls them,” Obergefell mentioned. To have these “rights chipped away or eroded going ahead may be very regarding to us – and me particularly.”

“I simply suppose we reached a spot and a time when we’ve to affirm the dignity and equal authorized rights of each human being,” Hodges mentioned.

Contributing: Richard Wolf, USA TODAY; Kate Sosin, the 19th


Present Thumbnails

Present Captions

Learn or Share this story: https://www.usatoday.com/story/information/2020/10/20/amy-coney-barrett-confirmation-could-threaten-lgbtq-rights-equality/3666505001/

Reader's opinions

Leave a Reply

Current track



Current show

Wake Up Call

5:00 am 6:30 am

Current show

Wake Up Call

5:00 am 6:30 am